How Large Is the Metabolome? A Critical Analysis of Data Exchange Practices in Chemistry Export

@article{citeulike:5663641, abstract = {Background Calculating the metabolome size of species by genome-guided reconstruction of metabolic pathways misses all products from orphan genes and from enzymes lacking annotated genes. Hence, metabolomes need to be determined experimentally. Annotations by mass spectrometry would greatly benefit if peer-reviewed public databases could be queried to compile target lists of structures that already have been reported for a given species. We detail current obstacles to compile such a knowledge base of metabolites. Results As an example, results are presented for rice. Two rice (oryza sativa) subspecies have been fully sequenced, oryza japonica and oryza indica. Several major small molecule databases were compared for listing known rice metabolites comprising PubChem, Chemical Abstracts, Beilstein, Patent databases, Dictionary of Natural Products, SetupX/BinBase, KNApSAcK DB, and finally those databases which were obtained by computational approaches, i.e. RiceCyc, KEGG, and Reactome. More than 5,000 small molecules were retrieved when searching these databases. Unfortunately, most often, genuine rice metabolites were retrieved together with non-metabolite database entries such as pesticides. Overlaps from database compound lists were very difficult to compare because structures were either not encoded in machine-readable format or because compound identifiers were not cross-referenced between databases. Conclusions We conclude that present databases are not capable of comprehensively retrieving all known metabolites. Metabolome lists are yet mostly restricted to genome-reconstructed pathways. We suggest that providers of (bio)chemical databases enrich their database identifiers to PubChem IDs and InChIKeys to enable cross-database queries. In addition, peer-reviewed journal repositories need to mandate submission of structures and spectra in machine readable format to allow automated semantic annotation of articles containing chemical structures. Such changes in publication standards and database architectures will enable researchers to compile current knowledge about the metabolome of species, which may extend to derived information such as spectral libraries, organ-specific metabolites, and cross-study comparisons.}, author = {Kind, Tobias and Scholz, Martin and Fiehn, Oliver}, citeulike-article-id = {5663641}, citeulike-linkout-0 = {http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0005440}, citeulike-linkout-1 = {http://view.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19415114}, citeulike-linkout-2 = {http://www.hubmed.org/display.cgi?uids=19415114}, day = {5}, doi = {10.1371/journal.pone.0005440}, issn = {1932-6203}, journal = {PLoS ONE}, keywords = {data, identifier, metabolism, miranda, standards}, month = {May}, number = {5}, pages = {e5440+}, posted-at = {2009-08-28 16:06:50}, priority = {2}, publisher = {Public Library of Science}, title = {How Large Is the Metabolome? A Critical Analysis of Data Exchange Practices in Chemistry}, url = {http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0005440}, volume = {4}, year = {2009} }

TY - JOUR ID - citeulike:5663641 L3 - citeulike-article-id:5663641 N2 - Background Calculating the metabolome size of species by genome-guided reconstruction of metabolic pathways misses all products from orphan genes and from enzymes lacking annotated genes. Hence, metabolomes need to be determined experimentally. Annotations by mass spectrometry would greatly benefit if peer-reviewed public databases could be queried to compile target lists of structures that already have been reported for a given species. We detail current obstacles to compile such a knowledge base of metabolites. Results As an example, results are presented for rice. Two rice (oryza sativa) subspecies have been fully sequenced, oryza japonica and oryza indica. Several major small molecule databases were compared for listing known rice metabolites comprising PubChem, Chemical Abstracts, Beilstein, Patent databases, Dictionary of Natural Products, SetupX/BinBase, KNApSAcK DB, and finally those databases which were obtained by computational approaches, i.e. RiceCyc, KEGG, and Reactome. More than 5,000 small molecules were retrieved when searching these databases. Unfortunately, most often, genuine rice metabolites were retrieved together with non-metabolite database entries such as pesticides. Overlaps from database compound lists were very difficult to compare because structures were either not encoded in machine-readable format or because compound identifiers were not cross-referenced between databases. Conclusions We conclude that present databases are not capable of comprehensively retrieving all known metabolites. Metabolome lists are yet mostly restricted to genome-reconstructed pathways. We suggest that providers of (bio)chemical databases enrich their database identifiers to PubChem IDs and InChIKeys to enable cross-database queries. In addition, peer-reviewed journal repositories need to mandate submission of structures and spectra in machine readable format to allow automated semantic annotation of articles containing chemical structures. Such changes in publication standards and database architectures will enable researchers to compile current knowledge about the metabolome of species, which may extend to derived information such as spectral libraries, organ-specific metabolites, and cross-study comparisons. IS - 5 JF - PLoS ONE SN - 1932-6203 TI - How Large Is the Metabolome? A Critical Analysis of Data Exchange Practices in Chemistry PB - Public Library of Science VL - 4 SP - e5440 KW - data KW - identifier KW - metabolism KW - miranda KW - standards AU - Kind, Tobias AU - Scholz, Martin AU - Fiehn, Oliver PY - 2009/05/05/ UR - http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0005440 ER -